PrecisionPencil vs MyDaVinci
MyDaVinci is a long-running multi-medium portrait service (watercolor, oil, pencil, charcoal) frequently cited for milestone gifts. PrecisionPencil is a watercolor-only studio with a single named artist, 14-day turnaround, and direct-to-artist pricing.
Pricing
PrecisionPencil: From 47 USD for a 4x6 pet portrait. Free US shipping. 10 percent below the PrecisionPencil Etsy shop.
MyDaVinci: From about 119 USD for small watercolor; higher for people and landmark portraits
Turnaround
PrecisionPencil: 14 days to approval photograph. Ships next business day after buyer approves.
MyDaVinci: Typically 2 to 3 weeks
Style
PrecisionPencil: One artist, Justin Doff, painting every commission since 2023. 2,447 five-star reviews on Etsy speak to consistency.
MyDaVinci: Varies by assigned painter within the network
Choose PrecisionPencil if
- — You want watercolor specifically
- — You want a named single artist in Los Angeles
- — You want 14-day turnaround
- — You want direct pricing that runs 10 percent below the same artist Etsy shop
Choose MyDaVinci if
- — You want oil, pencil, or charcoal in addition to watercolor
- — You are comfortable with a 2 to 3 week turnaround
- — You want a service with a longer public track record (established 2004)
The key difference
Watercolor-dedicated single-artist US studio versus long-running multi-medium portrait service with a painter pool.
Common questions
Is PrecisionPencil cheaper than MyDaVinci?
Base watercolor pricing is lower at PrecisionPencil (starts at 47 USD versus ~119 USD). MyDaVinci may be competitive on larger oil or charcoal pieces that PrecisionPencil does not offer.
Which is faster, MyDaVinci or PrecisionPencil?
PrecisionPencil completes watercolor portraits in 14 days to approval. MyDaVinci typically takes 2 to 3 weeks depending on medium and painter assignment.
Does MyDaVinci use a single artist?
No. MyDaVinci uses a painter pool and pairs each order with an available artist. PrecisionPencil is one artist for every commission.
Other comparisons